Direct vs regular mutual fund plans: expense ratio and switching

Direct vs regular mutual fund plans explained: what the expense ratio is, SEBI's 2026 limits, how commission works, the cost of a 1% gap and tax on switching.

Two coin jars showing how costs differ in direct vs regular mutual fund plans
Same fund, different costs: direct and regular plans drift apart over time. Illustration: AI-generated.

Key points

  • Direct plans carry no distributor commission, so their expense ratio is lower and their NAV grows faster than the regular plan of the same scheme.
  • Under the SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 2026, the capped base expense ratio is shown separately from brokerage, transaction costs and statutory levies.
  • Base expense ratio caps start at 2.10% for equity-oriented and 1.85% for other open-ended schemes on the first ₹500 crore, and 0.90% for index funds and ETFs.
  • Distributors are paid trail commission only; upfront commission is not allowed.
  • Switching from a regular to a direct plan is a redemption, so capital gains tax and exit loads can apply.

Two neighbours start a ₹10,000 monthly SIP in the same equity scheme on the same day. Same fund manager, same shares, same everything. Twenty years later, one of them has roughly ₹8 lakh more. The only difference is that one chose the direct plan and the other the regular plan. That, in short, is the direct vs regular mutual fund question, and the answer comes down to one number: the expense ratio.

This guide explains what the expense ratio is, the limits SEBI sets on it under the new mutual fund regulations that took effect on 1 April 2026, how distributor commission is paid, and how a gap of one percentage point grows over the years. It also covers how to move from a regular plan to a direct plan, and the tax you may pay when you switch.

What the expense ratio is

Every mutual fund scheme has running costs: the fund manager’s fee, registrar and custodian charges, audit, marketing and, in regular plans, the distributor’s commission. These are charged to the scheme as a percentage of its assets each year, and the figure is called the total expense ratio, or TER.

You never get a bill. The cost is taken out a little every day before the NAV is declared, so the NAV you see is already net of expenses. A scheme with a 1.5% TER that earns 12% before costs gives you about 10.5%.

Under the SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 2026, the TER is now built in four parts:

  • Base expense ratio (BER): management fee, other operating expenses and distribution commission. This is the part SEBI caps.
  • Brokerage: what the scheme pays to buy and sell securities, allowed over and above the BER up to 0.06% of trade value in the cash market and 0.02% in derivatives.
  • Transaction costs of executing trades.
  • Statutory levies such as GST, which sit outside the cap and are shown separately.

No other charges can be levied on investors apart from these and any exit load. The split makes it easier to see what the fund house actually keeps.

SEBI limits on the expense ratio

For most open-ended schemes, the maximum BER falls as the scheme grows, because a bigger scheme spreads its fixed costs over more money. The limits below apply to the daily net assets of a scheme.

Slab of scheme assets Equity-oriented schemes Other schemes
First ₹500 crore 2.10% 1.85%
Next ₹250 crore 1.90% 1.65%
Next ₹1,250 crore 1.60% 1.40%
Next ₹3,000 crore 1.50% 1.25%
Next ₹5,000 crore 1.40% 1.15%
Next ₹40,000 crore Cut by 0.05% for every ₹5,000 crore or part of it
Balance 0.95% 0.70%

Some schemes have flat caps instead. Index funds and ETFs can charge a BER of at most 0.90%. Fund of funds that invest in liquid schemes, index funds and ETFs are capped at 0.90%, those putting at least 65% in equity schemes at 2.10%, and other fund of funds at 1.85%, all including the cost of the underlying schemes. Close-ended equity schemes are capped at 1% and other close-ended schemes at 0.80%.

These are ceilings, not the actual charge. Most large schemes charge less, and the direct plan of any scheme always charges less than its regular plan.

To find the actual figure, look at the scheme’s monthly factsheet or the fund house website, which show the current TER of both plans side by side. The gap between the two plans of the same scheme is, in effect, the distribution cost you pay each year. Fund houses can change the TER within the limits, so look at it again whenever you review your portfolio, not only when you first invest.

Direct vs regular mutual fund plans: what actually differs

Since a SEBI circular of September 2012, every fund house must offer a separate plan for investments not routed through a distributor. This direct plan must have a lower expense ratio that excludes distribution expenses and commission, no commission may be paid from it, and it has its own NAV.

Everything else is the same. A direct plan and a regular plan of a scheme share one portfolio, one fund manager, one investment strategy and one risk level. The only difference is cost, and because the direct plan’s cost is lower, its NAV grows a little faster every single day.

That is why the NAVs drift apart. A scheme’s direct and regular plans may both have started at ₹10, but after ten years the direct plan’s NAV will be visibly higher. If you compare returns across plans, always compare direct with direct and regular with regular.

Direct plans pay no distributor commission, so they must carry a lower expense ratio and a separate NAV.

How distributor commission works

When you invest through a bank, a mutual fund distributor or many investment apps that offer regular plans, the distributor is paid by the fund house out of the scheme’s expenses. You do not write a separate cheque, which is why many people think the service is free. It is not. You pay through the higher expense ratio.

Since October 2018, SEBI has required fund houses to follow a full trail model of commission in all schemes. That means no upfront commission and no advance payment of trail commission in cash, kind or any other route. The distributor earns a trail: a percentage of the value of your investment every year for as long as you stay invested.

Two things follow from this. First, the commission grows as your money grows. A trail on ₹50 lakh is ten times the trail on ₹5 lakh, even if the distributor does no extra work. Second, the distributor has an interest in keeping you invested, which can be good, because it discourages panic selling, but it does not by itself guarantee good advice.

How a small cost gap compounds

A gap of one percentage point a year sounds trivial. Over long periods it is not. Here is an illustration with assumed numbers: a scheme earns 11% a year before costs, the direct plan costs 0.7% a year and the regular plan 1.7%. These are round figures for illustration, not the charges of any real scheme.

Investment over 20 years (illustration) Direct plan (net 10.3%) Regular plan (net 9.3%) Difference
SIP of ₹10,000 a month about ₹79.6 lakh about ₹69.9 lakh about ₹9.7 lakh
One-time ₹5 lakh about ₹35.5 lakh about ₹29.6 lakh about ₹5.9 lakh

The SIP figures assume monthly compounding at one-twelfth of the yearly rate, the same method as the site’s SIP calculator. In the SIP case, you put in ₹24 lakh in both plans. The regular plan leaves you with about ₹9.7 lakh less, more than a third of everything you invested. The gap widens each year because the money lost to costs also stops compounding.

You can run your own numbers on the SIP calculator or the lumpsum calculator. Enter the same return twice, once reduced by the direct plan’s TER and once by the regular plan’s, and look at the difference at your own time horizon.

When a regular plan can still make sense

The direct vs regular mutual fund choice is not only about cost. A regular plan pays for a service, and for some people that service is worth it. A good distributor helps with paperwork, nominations, KYC changes and, most of all, behaviour: talking you out of stopping your SIP in a market fall can be worth more than the commission.

The question to ask is whether you are getting that service. If you never hear from your distributor except when a new fund is launched, you are paying for something you do not receive. Another route is to pay a SEBI-registered investment adviser a fee for advice and invest in direct plans yourself. You then know exactly what you pay for advice. For a large portfolio, a flat yearly fee can work out cheaper than a trail that keeps rising with your balance, though for a small portfolio the trail may cost less.

If you pick funds yourself, review them once a year and can stay calm in a crash, the direct plan is the cheaper way to own the same fund.

How to switch from a regular to a direct plan

Moving is straightforward, but do it in order:

  1. List your holdings from your consolidated account statement and mark which are regular plans.
  2. Check the exit load on each scheme. Many schemes charge a load if you redeem within a set period, and a switch counts as a redemption.
  3. Work out the gain on each holding and how long you have held it, so you know the tax.
  4. Stop the SIP in the regular plan and register a new SIP in the direct plan of the same scheme. This costs nothing in tax because no units are sold.
  5. Submit a switch request for existing units through the fund house’s website, the registrar’s portal or an app that offers direct plans.

Your KYC stays valid. Only the plan changes.

Tax on switching

A switch from a regular plan to a direct plan, even within the same scheme, is treated as selling units of one plan and buying units of another. So any gain on the regular plan units is taxable in the year you switch.

For equity-oriented funds, units held for 12 months or less give short-term gains taxed at 20%. Units held longer give long-term gains taxed at 12.5%, and the first ₹1.25 lakh of long-term gains on listed equity and equity-oriented funds in a year is exempt. Gains on debt funds bought on or after 1 April 2023 are taxed at your slab rate whatever the holding period.

That gives you a simple plan for large equity holdings. Switch only the units that are more than 12 months old, and spread the switch over two or three financial years so that each year’s long-term gain stays near the ₹1.25 lakh exemption. Say you hold ₹6 lakh in a regular plan with ₹3 lakh of long-term gain: switching half in March and half in April splits the gain across two years and could keep most of it tax-free.

Key takeaways

  • The expense ratio is deducted daily from the NAV; you never see it as a bill.
  • Under SEBI’s 2026 rules, the capped base expense ratio is shown separately from brokerage, transaction costs and taxes.
  • Direct plans pay no commission, so they cost less and their NAV grows faster than the regular plan of the same scheme.
  • Distributors earn trail commission on your growing balance; there is no upfront commission.
  • A one percentage point cost gap can cost lakhs over 20 years.
  • Switching is a sale for tax purposes: check exit loads and gains, and spread large switches across financial years.

What it means for you

If you hold regular plans without receiving real advice, moving new SIPs to direct plans costs nothing in tax and can add lakhs to your corpus over 15 to 20 years.

SIP Calculator Lumpsum Calculator

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a direct and a regular plan?

A direct plan is for investments not routed through a distributor. SEBI requires it to have a lower expense ratio that excludes distribution expenses and commission, no commission is paid from it, and it has a separate NAV. The portfolio is the same as the regular plan.

What is the maximum expense ratio SEBI allows?

For open-ended equity-oriented schemes, the base expense ratio cap is 2.10% on the first ₹500 crore of daily net assets, falling in slabs to 0.95% on the balance. For other schemes it starts at 1.85% and falls to 0.70%. Index funds and ETFs are capped at 0.90%.

What is the base expense ratio?

Under the SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 2026, the base expense ratio covers the scheme's management, operating and distribution expenses, excluding statutory levies and transaction costs. Brokerage up to 0.06% of trade value in the cash market and 0.02% in derivatives can be charged over and above it.

Do distributors get upfront commission?

No. Since SEBI's October 2018 circular, fund houses must follow a full trail model of commission in all schemes, without upfront commission or upfronting of trail commission.

Is switching from a regular plan to a direct plan taxable?

Yes. A switch is treated as redemption of units in one plan and purchase in another, so capital gains tax applies. For equity-oriented funds, short-term gains are taxed at 20% and long-term gains at 12.5% above the yearly ₹1.25 lakh exemption.

Sources

  1. SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 2026 (last amended 10 October 2026) — SEBI
  2. Circular CIR/IMD/DF/21/2012: Steps to re-energize mutual fund industry (direct plans) — SEBI
  3. Total Expense Ratio (TER) and Performance Disclosure for Mutual Funds (October 2018) — SEBI
  4. CBDT FAQs on the new capital gains tax regime — Press Information Bureau, CBDT
  5. Taxation of specified mutual funds under section 50AA — TaxGuru

This article is for information only and is not investment, tax or legal advice. Figures are from the sources linked above as of the publish or update time. Please verify with official sources or a qualified adviser before making financial decisions.